25 Best Restaurants in New Paltz

Welcome to the flourishing restaurant scene in New Paltz, where you will find mouthwatering flavors, various cuisines, and experiences you will never forget. 

New Paltz is a scenic town in New York known for its abundant history, stunning natural beauty, and exceptional selection of dining establishments. This town is known for its location in the center of the Hudson Valley, which is known for its picturesque setting. 

So, are you looking for where to eat in New Paltz? From cozy cafes serving up freshly brewed artisanal coffee to elegant fine dining establishments, in this post, we will unveil the top restaurants in New Paltz in different cuisines. So whether you love Italian or Brazilian cuisine, we got you covered. Make sure to stick until the end.

Best Restaurants in New Paltz

1. Best Italian Cuisine- A Tavola Trattoria

Set in the lovely Hudson Valley area, immerse yourself in a gastronomic experience that embraces the bright flavors of Italy in A Tavola Trattoria. This is one of the best restaurants in New Paltz NY. 

For over a decade, this acclaimed restaurant has been delighting New Paltz locals and visitors with its authentic Italian cuisine and constant commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients.

The restaurant translates to “at the table” in Italian, welcoming visitors to meet and feast on wonderful cuisine.  As you step into the restaurant, you’ll be greeted by a contemporary yet inviting ambiance that seamlessly blends rustic charm with modern elements.

What to Eat:

Try their delightful orecchiette dish. This combines the robust essence of Italian sausage with the peppery freshness of arugula and the vibrant sweetness of peppers.

The pork marsala is another signature creation that is a true delight for pork lovers, tossed with a medley of vibrant, sautéed vegetables and combined perfectly with their marsala sauce

2. Best American Cuisine- Main Street Bistro

Nestled in the heart of downtown New Paltz, the iconic Main Street Bistro has become a beloved culinary institution since its establishment in 1993. Renowned as a family-friendly dining destination, Main Street Bistro has become synonymous with exceptional cuisine and warm hospitality, making it a top choice for locals and visitors when seeking the perfect place to dine.

Main Street Bistro is committed to catering to various dietary preferences, with an impressive selection of vegetarian options. They have also earned accolades for their exceptional catering services. 

Conveniently located within a mere two-minute drive from the State University of New York in New Paltz, Main Street Bistro has become a cherished gathering place for students, faculty, and the local community. 

What to Eat:

Dive into the iconic 59 Main X breakfast, a mouthwatering combination of fluffy scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, melted cheddar cheese, and homemade fries that will tantalize your taste buds. Topped with zesty salsa and a dollop of creamy sour cream.  

3. Best Farm-to-Table Restaurant- Main Course Catering and Marketplace (Also Known As Main Course Restaurant

Experience the vibrant flavors of the Hudson Valley at Main Course, a farm-to-table eatery that takes pride in serving fresh and locally sourced food. With a commitment to supporting local farmers and producers, Main Course offers a delightful array of dishes highlighting the region’s bountiful harvest.

While Main Course is renowned for its catering services and serves daily specials from Tuesdays to Sundays. They also offer a range of gluten-free choices, ensuring everyone can partake in the culinary delights. 

With a successful three-decade history, it has established itself as a trusted and beloved establishment in New Paltz, making it an ideal choice for a memorable meal with friends and family.

What to Eat:

Indulge in the flavorful and vibrant Huevos Rancheros. This tantalizing dish combines perfectly cooked eggs with hearty black beans, zesty salsa, creamy cheese, luscious avocado,  and warm tortillas.

For those seeking a lighter option, the Frittata is another best and comes with a side of mixed green salad is a must-try.

4. Best Seafood Restaurant- Gadaleto’s Seafood

Gadaleto’s Seafood is an eco-friendly diner in the town’s heart. With its charming ambiance and commitment to sustainable practices, this dining establishment has been one of the places to eat New Platz, NY.

Since its establishment in 1979, Gadaleto’s Seafood has been dedicated to delivering an exceptional dining experience centered around high-quality, sustainably sourced seafood. 

While Gadaleto’s Seafood may not boast an extravagant setting, its unpretentious charm is part of its allure.  In addition to the delightful dining experience, the restaurant also offers a unique opportunity to take the freshest seafood home with you. 

What to Eat:

Sample their irresistible Captain’s Combo. This mouthwatering dish features a delightful combination of tender crab-stuffed soles, succulent scallops, and plump shrimp.

For those who prefer their seafood fried to golden perfection, Gadaleto’s Seafood offers the option to have the Captain’s Combo served with fry baskets. Also, consider adding the BBQ Grilled Shrimp Sandwich to your order. 

5. Best Mexican Restaurant- Los Jalapeños

Experience the vibrant flavors of Mexico at Los Jalapeños, a standout go to place that has been delighting the taste buds of New Paltz with Mexican flavors since its opening in 2015. Conveniently located in Chestnut ST, just half a mile from Hasbrouck Park, this establishment is a must-visit destination.

Los Jalapeños welcomes guests with its fast-casual dining concept, offering a relaxed and comfortable atmosphere that makes it a perfect choice, even for newcomers to the city. 

While the authentic Mexican atmosphere sets the stage, the true highlight of Los Jalapeños lies in its exceptional food, using the freshest ingredients and authentic recipes.

What to Eat:

For those seeking the most popular choices, look no further than the classic beef burrito and beef enchilada. Be sure also to try their grilled salmon, one of the restaurant’s delightful specials.

6. Best French Cuisine- RŪNA

RŪNA, originally a French-inspired restaurant, has expanded its culinary offerings to include a variety of cuisines from around the world. Since its establishment in September 2019, RŪNA has embraced the flavors of North Africa, the Basque region, and Vietnam, creating a unique dining experience that caters to diverse tastes. 

Located near the village hall of New Paltz, RŪNA presents itself as an excellent choice when you cannot decide which cuisine to indulge in for the day. 

In addition to its diverse and enticing menu, RŪNA sets itself apart as one of the best birthday restaurants in New Paltz. With three dining rooms available on-site, they have the capacity to accommodate larger groups and create a memorable and celebratory atmosphere.

What to Eat:

For those looking to elevate their date night, RŪNA offers a sip of the François Ducrot Auguste Orange Wine from France. If you’re seeking a lighter alternative, they also have a varied burger selection, making a satisfying dining experience.

7. Best Thai Cuisine- Bangkok Cafe

Nestled in the heart of New Paltz, Bangkok Cafe has been delighting diners with its exquisite Thai cuisine for over 20 years. It has become a destination for those seeking authentic and flavorful Thai dishes.

Complementing the tantalizing food, Bangkok Cafe features a full bar that offers an impressive selection of Thai beers, sakes, and cocktails. Guests can savor the refreshing taste of Thai beers such as Singha or Chang, or explore the nuanced flavors of different sakes.

Step inside Bangkok Cafe, and you’ll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The cozy seating arrangements, adorned with Thai-inspired decor, create a setting that is perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family. 

What to Eat:

Noodle enthusiasts can indulge in classic favorites like Pad Thai or delve into the savory goodness of dishes like Pad See Ew. Rice lovers can enjoy aromatic and flavorful options like Pineapple Fried Rice or fragrant Jasmine Rice paired with delectable Thai curries.

8. Best Indian Restaurant- New Paltz Indian Restaurant

New Paltz Indian Restaurant is a culinary gem in the heart of New Paltz, offering an authentic taste of Indian cuisine. With its rich flavors, vibrant spices, and diverse menu, the restaurant has become a beloved destination for locals and visitors seeking a memorable dining experience.

The menu at New Paltz Indian Restaurant showcases the diverse and exquisite flavors of Indian cuisine, from aromatic curries to flavorful biryanis.

When it comes to the best time to visit New Paltz Indian Restaurant, making reservations during peak hours or on weekends is recommended, as the restaurant tends to be popular and can get quite busy.

What to Eat:

Their Chicken Tikka Masala is a classic favorite and beloved Indian dish featuring tender grilled chicken cooked in a creamy tomato-based sauce. 

Another popular choice is the flavorful and aromatic Biryani, a fragrant rice dish layered with tender meat or vegetables and a blend of spices.

9. Best Vietnamese Restaurant- IPho

Nestled in the heart of downtown New Paltz, NY, IPho is a Vietnamese restaurant that has quickly become a go-to destination for those seeking authentic Asian cuisine. The restaurant takes its name from Vietnam’s beloved national dish, “Pho,” a flavorful soup that has gained worldwide recognition.

Whether you’re a seasoned fan of Vietnamese cuisine or new to its tantalizing flavors, IPho provides the perfect opportunity to embark on a culinary adventure.

What sets IPho apart is its accessibility, conveniently located near the top attractions in town. After exploring the sights and sounds of New Paltz, you can recharge and refuel at this casual restaurant.

What to Eat:

For a taste of the iconic Vietnamese dish that put IPho on the map, don’t miss the opportunity to savor their special beef pho. This aromatic and steaming bowl of goodness is a symphony of flavors, featuring tender beef, fragrant herbs, and perfectly cooked rice noodles swimming in a rich and flavorful broth.

10. Best Dinner- P&G’s

P&G’s diner is a haven for food enthusiasts and a treasure trove of history, making it a must-visit destination for history lovers. Established in 1947, this family-owned and operated restaurant is housed within a charming dance hall that dates back to 1900.

As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the echoes of the past and a sense of the rich heritage surrounding this iconic establishment.

From juicy burgers and crispy fries to delectable sandwiches and mouthwatering milkshakes, the menu is a delight for those seeking classic comfort foods. Beyond its delectable offerings, P&G is a fantastic hangout spot for those seeking vibrant nightlife in New Paltz.

What to Eat:

Don’t miss the opportunity to savor the curry scallops, a culinary masterpiece that combines plump and succulent scallops with a fragrant and aromatic curry sauce. If you’re in the mood for pub classics, P&G’s has you covered with their Guinness Battered Fish-N-Chips and Fried Shrimp. 

11. Best For Vegetarians- Karma Road Organic Cafe’

Imagine a truly fulfilling dining experience at Karma Road Organic Café, where delicious food awaits and a sense of good karma and environmental consciousness.

 The café’s inception was inspired by the visionary founder, a devoted vegetarian for decades, whose passion for wholesome and conscious eating led to the creation of this remarkable culinary haven. Additionally, the café offers a wide array of gluten-free house salad. 

This is also conveniently located near the State University of New York, Karma Road Organic Café is just a leisurely stroll less than 10 minutes away. 

What to Eat:

Avocado enthusiasts are in for a treat at Karma Road Organic Café with their signature Avocado Explosion. This delightful dish combines the creaminess of ripe avocados with a medley of crisp carrots, refreshing sunflower greens, and a luscious tahini dressing. 

12. Best Casual Restaurant- Lola’s Cafe

Regarding casual dining experiences, Lola’s Café is a must-visit spot that promises both comfort and delectable cuisine. Nestled in the heart of New Paltz, this beloved delicious pit stop has been winning the hearts of locals and tourists alike since its opening in 2017. 

Lola’s Café first established its roots in Poughkeepsie in 2005, and its success led to the expansion of its second location just 12 miles away. As you step into Lola’s Café, you’ll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, with rustic touches and charming wooden floors that exude a cozy and welcoming vibe.

Lola’s Café also provides a delightful outdoor dining experience for those who enjoy dining al fresco. 

What to Eat:

One dish that stands out among their offerings is Lola’s Turkey Club. This timeless sandwich features a combination of roasted turkey, crispy bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato, all nestled between two slices of toasted bread.

To add an extra burst of flavor, a drizzle of creamy ranch dressing is the perfect finishing touch.

13. Best Casual Restaurant- Huckleberry

Searching for restaurants near New Paltz NY? Look no further than Huckleberry, the charming bar and eatery that opened its doors in the New Paltz area back in December 2015. With its relaxed atmosphere and welcoming ambiance, Huckleberry appeals to people of all ages.

Conveniently located just a few steps from Main Street, Huckleberry is easily accessible, saving you the hassle of searching for a place off the beaten path.

One of the highlights of Huckleberry is its inviting patio area, which offers a picturesque setting for relaxation and socializing. Furthermore, Huckleberry’s bar is open until midnight, providing ample time to hang out and enjoy your evening to the fullest.

What to Eat:

For those who crave a little heat and spice, the Nashville Hot Chicken Sandwich is an absolute must-try.

To complement your meal, Huckleberry offers a unique and refreshing cocktail called the Lightning Bug, made from Bison grass vodka and sparkling wine with the zing of lemon.

14.  Best Japanese Cuisine- Hokkaido

Hokkaido Restaurant, nestled in the heart of New Paltz, has been delighting diners with its delectable Japanese cuisine for over 20 years. As a longstanding establishment, it has established a reputation for delivering authentic Japanese culinary experiences.

Complementing the delicious food, Hokkaido Restaurant offers a full bar with an impressive selection of Japanese beers, sakes, and cocktails. Guests can pair their meal with a refreshing Japanese beer, such as Sapporo, Sake or Asahi.

The comfortable seating, soft lighting, and tasteful decor create a setting perfect for enjoying a meal with friends or family. 

What to Eat:

Sample their Hokkaido Scallop Roll made with fresh Hokkaido scallops, avocado, cucumber, and tobiko (flying fish roe). It is then topped with a special sauce and eel sauce. Their Tempura Udon is another must-try. This dish is made with udon noodles that are lightly battered and fried. They are then served in a hot broth with vegetables and shrimp tempura. 

15. Best for Pizza- Pasquale’s

For over 50 years, Pasquale’s has been a beloved Italian restaurant in the heart of New Paltz, proudly owned and operated by a family dedicated to providing exceptional dining experiences. 

Regarding their pizzas, Pasquale’s takes great pride in crafting each one with care and passion. Using their own homemade dough and sauce, they ensure that every pizza is made with the finest ingredients and attention to detail. The menu offers extensive toppings, allowing guests to customize their pizzas.

To achieve the perfect pizza, Pasquale’s uses a traditional brick baking oven. Furthermore, Pasquale’s extends its hospitality beyond its restaurant walls by offering convenient delivery and take-out options.

What to Eat:

Some of the most popular pizzas include the Margherita, the Pepperoni, and the Veggie. Pasquale’s also offers a variety of pasta dishes, including spaghetti, fettuccine alfredo, and lasagna. The pasta is made fresh daily, and it is cooked to perfection.

16. Best German Pub- Schatzi’s Pub and Bier Garden

Nestled in the heart of New Paltz, Schatzi’s Pub and Bier Garden has been a hidden gem for German cuisine and beer enthusiasts for over 20 years.  It is one of the best New Paltz eateries. 

The menu at Schatzi’s Pub and Bier Garden showcases an array of mouthwatering German dishes, guaranteeing a delightful culinary experience. From the classic and comforting schnitzels to an assortment of flavorful sausages that tantalize the taste buds, each dish embodies German cuisine’s authentic flavors and techniques. 

One of the highlights of Schatzi’s is its expansive beer garden, which provides an inviting and laid-back atmosphere, making it an ideal spot to unwind and embrace the vibrant ambiance.

What to Eat:

Sample the classic Schnitzel, a dish made with a breaded and fried meat cutlet, typically veal or pork. It is usually served with a side of potatoes and vegetables. You should also not forget to order their Spaetzle. This German noodle dish is made with flour, eggs, and water. It is usually served with a sauce, such as a cheese or brown butter sauce.

17. Best New American Fare- Garvan’s Gastropub

Nestled in the heart of New Paltz, Garvan’s Gastropub has been a culinary gem for over ten years, serving up mouthwatering gastropub fare that satisfies a range of tastes. As a gastropub, it prides itself on offering elevated and inventive dishes in a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.

The menu at Garvan’s Gastropub boasts an impressive array of flavorful dishes, ensuring that there is something for everyone to enjoy. Each bite is a tantalizing explosion of flavors, from juicy and perfectly seasoned burgers to stacked sandwiches filled with delectable ingredients. 

Complementing the good food, Garvan’s Gastropub boasts a full bar that caters to beverage enthusiasts. They are also renowned for their warm and inviting atmosphere.

What to Eat:

Try their Garvan’s Special Pizza with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers. It is a popular choice for both locals and tourists alike. Their Classic Cheeseburger is another crowd-favorite, made with fresh, high-quality beef and perfectly cooked. 

18. Best for Breakfast- Plaza Diner

Plaza Diner is a beloved establishment located in St New Paltz NY, offering a delightful dining experience for locals and visitors alike. With its welcoming atmosphere, extensive menu, and friendly service, Plaza Diner has become a go-to spot for delicious comfort food and satisfying meals.

The menu at Plaza Diner is diverse and expansive, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. From hearty breakfast options to mouthwatering burgers, sandwiches, salads, and classic diner fare, there is something for everyone to enjoy.

 It is typically busiest during peak breakfast and brunch hours, especially on weekends when locals and tourists gather to enjoy a leisurely meal.

What to Eat:

Among their best-selling dishes is the Greek Salad, packed with fresh vegetables, feta cheese, and olives, which offers a refreshing and flavorful option for those seeking a lighter meal.

The Plaza Burger, made with juicy beef patties and topped with your choice of toppings, is a crowd-pleaser that satisfies cravings for a classic American burger. 

19. Best Cajun Classics- The Parish

Cajun cuisine is served at The Parish, a restaurant that may be found in the middle of New Paltz. It is one of the best places to eat in New Platz New York, and has been offering delectable Cajun cuisine since it opened more than five years ago. 

Po’boys, gumbo, and jambalaya are just a few of the many delicious meals that can be found on the menu’s extensive selection. 

Since the restaurant is at its busiest on the weekends, it is strongly recommended that you make reservations if you intend to dine there over the weekend. A happy hour is also held at the restaurant from 4 to 7 o’clock in the evening, Monday through Friday. 

What to Eat:

Try their Jambalaya, a rice dish made with a variety of meats and vegetables, including chicken, sausage, and shrimp. It is cooked in a tomato-based sauce and served with a side of bread.

If you want something warm, order their Gumbo, a soup made with a dark roux, chicken stock, and a variety of meats and vegetables, including shrimp, sausage, and okra.

 20. Casual Pan-Asian Restaurant- Asian Fusion

Asian Fusion, located in the heart of New Paltz NY 12561, is a culinary gem that combines Asia’s vibrant flavors and diverse cuisines. With its fusion approach, blending traditional recipes with innovative twists, Asian Fusion offers a unique and exciting dining experience for both locals and visitors.

The menu at Asian Fusion showcases a harmonious blend of excellent food from various Asian cuisines, including Chinese, Japanese, Thai, and Vietnamese. Each dish is carefully crafted using authentic ingredients and culinary techniques.

Making reservations during peak hours, especially on weekends, is generally recommended as the restaurant can get busy due to its popularity.

What to Eat:

The General Tso’s Chicken, a classic Chinese dish, features crispy chicken tossed in a tangy and slightly spicy sauce, creating a perfect balance of flavors.  The Sushi Platter is another must-try, offering an assortment of fresh and beautifully presented sushi rolls, showcasing Japanese cuisine’s artistry. 

21. Best Fining Dining- Mohonk Mountain House Restaurant

Mohonk Mountain House, nestled amidst the picturesque Catskill Mountains, offers a Victorian-themed hotel experience with a relaxed and elegant dining venue. The hotel’s dining area boasts stunning panoramic views making it one of the best Paltz restaurants.

While it is approximately six miles from the bustling downtown area of New Paltz, its secluded location adds to its charm and allure. The serenity and tranquillity of the surroundings make it one of the most sought-after dining destinations in the entire New Paltz area.

From breakfast to dinner, the menu features a wide range of options, including farm-fresh ingredients, locally sourced produce, and various culinary influences.

What to Eat:

The Caesar salad is perfect for a refreshing and classic lunch start. It has crisp romaine lettuce tossed in a tangy Caesar dressing, shaved Parmesan cheese and homemade croutons. 

Seafood enthusiasts will delight in the pan-seared Idaho Rainbow Trout, a dish that showcases the delicate flavors and tender texture of this popular freshwater fish.

 22. Best Mexican-inspired Cuisine- Mexican Kitchen

Mexican Kitchen, a beloved establishment that has been serving the New Paltz community for over half a decade, brings the vibrant flavors and lively atmosphere of Mexico to the heart of the town. 

Inspired by the neighborhood restaurants commonly found throughout Mexico, Mexican Kitchen offers an authentic dining experience that transports guests to the bustling streets of Mexico.

Whether you’re in the mood for tacos filled with succulent meats, flavorful burritos bursting with ingredients, or traditional Mexican favorites like enchiladas and quesadillas, Mexican Kitchen has you covered. 

What to Eat:

If you’re a fan of shredded pork, don’t miss the opportunity to enhance your dining experience by adding a carnitas-flavored quesadilla to your order. 

The black bean soup is a fantastic choice for those seeking a lighter option. This vegetarian and gluten-free soup is a comforting and hearty dish that is sure to warm your tummy.

23. Best for Burgers- Burger Box

Burger Box, a recent addition to the vibrant culinary scene of New Paltz, opened its doors in 2021, captivating food enthusiasts with its unique take on iconic American fare.

Founded by a dynamic duo of sisters, Burger Box is a testament to their passion for delivering great food and exceptional dining experiences while infusing their own creative twist into classic dishes.

Although relatively new in the industry, Burger Box has quickly gained recognition as one of the premier restaurants in New Paltz. In addition to its delectable food offerings, Burger Box also showcases a wine bar and the best of New York’s beverage scene. 

What to Eat:

For those who seek a bolder flavor profile, the spicy barbecue burger is an excellent choice. Be sure to pair your burger with Burger Box’s famous fresh-cut fries.  If you’re feeling adventurous, Burger Box also offers the opportunity to build your own burger.

 24. Best Grill House- The Grille

The Grille is a traditional American steakhouse in the middle of New Paltz. For almost 20 years, it has been providing great steak and seafood. 

The menu includes many options, such as fillet mignon, lobster tail, and New York strip. There is also a complete bar with a selection of American beers, wines, and cocktails.

The restaurant is extremely popular during the summer months, so if you plan to visit during this period, arrive early. Monday through Friday, from 4 pm to 7 pm, the restaurant also offers a happy hour, which is a fantastic chance to taste some of the cuisine and drinks at a discounted price.

What to Eat:

Sample their Filet Mignon. This steak is made with a high-quality cut of beef and is cooked to perfection. It is typically served with a side of mashed potatoes and asparagus. They are also famous for their New York Strip, served with grilled vegetables and a baked potato.

 25. Best American Pub Food- Murphy’s

Murphy’s Restaurant and Pub in New Paltz was famous for its relaxed atmosphere, courteous service, and delectable food.  This is a favorite New Platz New York restaurant.

John Murphy, a local businessman and entrepreneur, created it in 1987. The restaurant was on Main Street in New Paltz and immediately became a popular destination for both locals and tourists.  

The menu included standard American meals such as burgers, sandwiches, salads, and pizzas. Murphy’s also had a complete bar with various beers, wines, and cocktails. Murphy’s is also noted for its live music on weekends, in addition to its cuisine and drinks. 

What to Eat:

The Murphy’s Burger is a classic popular choice for locals and tourists. It is known for its juicy, flavorful patty and fresh, crisp toppings. The burger was also affordable and a great value for the price.

Conclusion:

The passion, creativity, and commitment of the chefs at these establishments are clearly visible in their innovative menus, exquisite presentation, and the unmatched tastes they offer. Whether it’s the sophisticated ambiance at A Tavola, or the homely feel of Main Street Bistro, each restaurant provides an experience that is as appealing to the palate as it is to the senses.

These establishments not only cater to a range of tastes but also accommodate various dietary preferences, making New Paltz a haven for food lovers of all kinds. They are an embodiment of the town’s commitment to local produce and sustainability, often featuring menus built around seasonal, locally sourced ingredients.

While the town’s restaurants offer a wide array of choices, the common thread is the commitment to quality and authenticity, which is visible in each dining experience. The culinary scene in New Paltz is dynamic, constantly evolving, and pushing boundaries while remaining rooted in the town’s unique identity.

So, whether you’re a local resident or a visitor exploring the town, New Paltz’s dining scene has something to satisfy every palate. We recommend embarking on this culinary journey, one restaurant at a time, to truly savor what this town has to offer. With its vast array of standout establishments, New Paltz certainly stakes a convincing claim as a must-visit destination for all food lovers.

FAQs:

Resources:

• (SuperTravel) SnapTravel Review: Is it Helpful for Travelers?
• Top Places to Travel Without a Passport from the US
• Travel Essentials for Women
• Is WayAway Legit? WayAway Review