15  Best Marco Island Restaurants

The sunny shores of Marco Island, Florida, are a gastronomic haven that mixes magnificent landscapes with outstanding dining experiences! Located in the Gulf of Mexico, it is the largest of Florida’s Ten Thousand Islands and is famed for its pure white sandy beaches, stunning sunsets, and abundance of wildlife. 

In addition to its natural beauty, it is also a thriving dining scene featuring the best restaurants in Marco Island, serving basic American fare to international flavors. Whether you’re a foodie looking for the latest gastronomic trends or simply looking for a calm seaside lunch, we’ve got you covered. This article will take you on a culinary adventure as we reveal the greatest Marco Island restaurant.

So make sure to read until the end. Bon appétit!

Best Marco Island Restaurants

One of the highlights of dining here is the opportunity to enjoy waterfront views while you dine. Many restaurants in Marco Island, FL offer stunning vistas of the Gulf of Mexico or the island’s picturesque canals, creating a truly memorable dining experience. So grab a pen and paper and lit these restaurants on your bucket list.

1. Best Italian Cuisine- Sale e Pepe

Sale e Pepe is a well-known upscale Italian restaurant and one of the best Marco Islands restaurants that provide memorable fine dining for lovers of Italian cuisine. This elegant restaurant in the center provides the Marco Beach Ocean Resort, and its sophisticated ambiance, combined with breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico, produces a really unforgettable dining experience.

The culinary staff at Sale e Pepe, directed by Executive Chef Antonio Minichiello, creates authentic Italian dishes using the finest local and imported products. The restaurant takes pride in its culinary expertise.

The best time to visit Sale e Pepe is during the winter months when Marco Island is at its busiest, which is usually from November through April. The weather is nice at this time of year, and the restaurant is bustling with activities, so reservations are recommended.

What to Eat:

There are several must-try Italian foods in this restaurant, and one of them is homemade pasta. Pastoral lovers will be in heaven, from the delicate and creamy Fettuccine Alfredo to the flavorful and robust Bucatini Carbonara. 

The Branzino, a Mediterranean sea bass, is a popular choice for seafood enthusiasts, cooked to perfection with delicate herbs and lemon. With options like the tender and flavorful Osso Buco, a slow-braised veal shank with gremolata, meat lovers won’t be disappointed either.

2. Best American Cuisine- La Tavola Restaurant and Bar

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar is a popular choice for people looking for the best American food in a cozy and welcoming setting. This restaurant’s broad menu celebrates classic American flavors with a modern touch, making it a favorite among locals and visitors.

As one of the best Marco Islands restaurants, the environment is welcoming. Soft lighting, rustic furnishings, and a laid-back vibe make it ideal for a casual eating experience. To add to its allure, the restaurant has a full-service bar equipped with an excellent assortment of wines, artisan cocktails, and beers.

La Tavola is always available for dinner, but reservations are strongly advised, especially during the high season. Aside from their dining room, the restaurant also has outside seating, so diners may enjoy the beautiful Marco Island weather while indulging in delectable American fare.

What to Eat:

A must-try for a meat lover’s dreams is their New York Strip Steak, grilled to perfection with a charred crust and juicy middle. Seafood enthusiasts will also like the Pan-Seared Scallops, which come with a lemon butter sauce and creamy risotto. 

Make sure also to get their Braised Short Ribs, slow-cooked to exquisite perfection and topped with creamy mashed potatoes, which are a crowd-pleaser for those looking for comfort cuisine.

3. Best French Cuisine-Bistro Soleil at the Olde Marco Inn

Bistro Soleil is a taste of France in the heart of Marco Island, Florida! It is known for its delicious French cuisine, pleasant environment, and impeccable service and is housed within the historic Olde Marco Inn.

It features a wonderful Parisian cafe atmosphere with its warm decor, exquisite décor, and shimmering candles. The compact environment is ideal for a romantic date night or a special occasion, where you can taste the flavors of France in a relaxed and welcoming ambiance.

The best time to visit Bistro Soleil is in the evening when the warm environment and candlelight tables come alive. The attentive and competent crew gives excellent service, which contributes to the overall eating experience. A romantic evening under the stars is also possible with the outdoor patio seats.

What to Eat:

The menu at Bistro Soleil is a celebration of classic French dishes prepared with finesse and attention to detail. 

The “Escargot de Bourgogne,” soft snails sautéed with garlic, butter, and parsley and served in their shells, is a must-try for every gourmet enthusiast. Another popular dish is the “Filet Mignon,” a perfectly cooked tenderloin steak covered with a thick red wine reduction sauce, which is a great delight for meat aficionados.

4. Best Seafood Restaurant- Snook Inn

Snook Inn is located on the gorgeous beaches of Marco Island, Florida. It has established a reputation as the best seafood restaurant in the area. It is a must-visit place for seafood aficionados and those looking for a great dining experience, thanks to its attractive setting, pleasant service, and scrumptious seafood delicacies.

It offers the welcoming environment of a traditional Floridian fish shack. The open-air seating allows you to take in the breathtaking waterfront scenery while relaxing in the salty wind. 

The best time to visit Snook Inn is during happy hour, which runs from 4 to 6 p.m. when you can enjoy reduced drinks and appetizers while watching the sunset over the sea. The restaurant also features live entertainment on select evenings, with local musicians providing a colorful soundtrack to your dining experience.

What to Eat:

Seafood is the ultimate star of the show.  One of the all-time favorites is the Snook Inn’s signature “Captain’s Platter,” a mouthwatering assortment of fried shrimp, scallops, oysters, and fish, served with crispy fries and coleslaw. 

Another must-try dish is the “Lobster Tail,” a perfectly grilled, buttery lobster tail that is simply divine. It also offers a variety of juicy steaks to flavorful chicken dishes for those looking for alternatives. 

5. Best Steakhouse- Marco Prime Steak & Seafood Restaurant

Source / License: TripAdvisor

Marco Prime, the top steakhouse and one of the top-rated restaurants in Marco Island provides an unsurpassed dining experience in terms of flavor, quality, and ambiance. This restaurant is located within the Marco Walk Plaza off South Collier Boulevard, so if you’re in the neighborhood, make sure to stop by.

You’ll be greeted by Marco Prime’s elegant and contemporary ambiance, which has chic décor, subdued lighting, and a cozy fireplace, creating the ideal ambiance for a special occasion or a great night out. 

The best time to visit Marco Prime is in the evening when the restaurant and refined environment comes alive. The varied wine list offers a diverse selection of great wines from throughout the world.

What to Eat:

The top Ribeye Steak is one of their best dishes.  This is a juicy and tasty ribeye cut offered with your choice of sauce or topping, such as truffle butter or blue cheese crust. Then savor the delicious and tender meat of their fresh lobster tail, which has been prepared with care and served with drawn butter. 

Finally, choose the loaded baked potato, a typical steakhouse side dish topped with crispy bacon, melted cheese, chives, and sour cream. 

6. Best for Breakfast- Doreen’s Cup of Joe

This is the place to go on Marco Island, Florida, for a delicious and filling breakfast. For years, this cozy and welcoming café has been a renowned neighborhood favorite, dishing you delectable breakfast dishes that will get your day started correctly.

Doreen’s Cup of Joe has a broad and delicious menu that includes classic breakfast favorites with a distinctive touch. From fluffy pancakes and delicious omelets to hearty breakfast sandwiches and delectable egg Benedicts, we have it all. 

The menu also contains options for individuals with dietary limitations, such as gluten-free and vegetarian selections, ensuring everyone’s taste buds are satisfied. It is best visited in the morning when the restaurant opens early to provide breakfast.

What to Eat:

One of Doreen’s Cup of Joe’s signature dishes is the “Joe’s Diner Skillet,” a hearty and tasty breakfast skillet loaded with eggs, potatoes, cheese, and your choice of meat or veggies. 

Make sure to pair it with their freshly brewed coffee and specialty beverages, including their distinctive “cup of joe.”

7. Best Salad Choices- CJ’s on The Bay

CJ’s on The Bay is one of the Marco Islands restaurants on the water that provides a memorable culinary experience. It is nestled along the gorgeous shores of Smokehouse Bay and features stunning waterfront views, a calm environment, and excellent food that will tempt your taste buds.

Their salad bar is excellent for those searching for a lighter and refreshing option, with everything from fresh greens and crisp veggies to tasty dressings and unique toppings. They also serve fresh seafood, succulent steaks, and pasta dishes, as well as an extensive drink menu that includes distinctive cocktails, a selected wine selection, and refreshing beverages to compliment your meal.

CJ’s on The Bay is best visited at sunset when the restaurant’s waterfront location provides beautiful views of the setting sun over the bay.

What to Eat:

Don’t leave without eating their signature Lobster Salad, which is made with luscious lobster meat, mixed greens, avocado, tomatoes, and a zesty vinaigrette. The Caprese Salad, which features fresh mozzarella, juicy tomatoes, basil, and a sprinkle of balsamic glaze for a blast of flavor, is also a fan favorite.

8. Best Oyster Dishes-The Oyster Society

As one of the best restaurants on Marco Island, this seafood restaurant promises to take your taste buds on a voyage with its scrumptious cuisine and refined ambiance.

The Oyster Society takes pride in delivering only the freshest seafood derived from local seas.  The elegant and soothing ambiance is created by the stylish decor, excellent service, and waterfront views, setting the mood for a wonderful dining experience. Their raw oyster bar offers a tantalizing range of oysters from various areas, shucked to order and served with traditional accompaniments such as lemon, horseradish, and mignonette sauce.  

The Oyster Society is best appreciated at night when the restaurant’s outstanding waterfront position provides a stunning background for a romantic sunset dinner. As the sun begins to set,  The Oyster Society transforms into an idyllic setting for a really unforgettable dining experience.

What to Eat:

Make a point of trying their Oysters Rockefeller. These fresh oysters are topped with a luscious blend of spinach, bacon, and Parmesan cheese before being cooked to perfection.  

Then get their Oyster Society Bouillabaisse, a robust fish stew cooked with a variety of shellfish, including fish, shrimp, clams, mussels, and squid, stewed in a thick tomato-based broth with aromatic herbs and spices.  For a lighter option, also try the Tuna Tartare, which features fresh, diced tuna mixed with avocado, cilantro, and citrus dressing. 

9. Best Tropical Beverages-Sunset Grille

The Sunset Grille on Marco Island is a busy and colorful restaurant noted for its tropical cocktails, great food, and breathtaking waterfront views. This restaurant, located directly on the ocean, is a favorite site for locals and travelers alike to have a taste of the tropics.

The ambiance is relaxed and inviting, with a laid-back island vibe that is ideal for sipping on delightful tropical cocktails. It’s a terrific location to relax, unwind, and enjoy the tropical feelings, thanks to the helpful personnel and vibrant ambiance.

Sunset Grille is best visited during sunset hours, as the name suggests. The restaurant’s riverside location affords stunning sunset views, creating a gorgeous backdrop for enjoying a tropical beverage and a tasty dinner.

What to Eat:

Fresh seafood selections such as Key West Pink Shrimp and Mahi Mahi are a must-try. Remember to leave space for dessert! Sweet delights such as Key Lime Pie, Chocolate Lava Cake, and Crème Brûlée are available too. 

Then get their Piña Colada for a relaxing sip. It’s a classic tropical cocktail made with rum, coconut cream, and pineapple juice mixed to creamy perfection. Another famous tiki drink is the Mai Tai, which blends rum, lime juice, orange liqueur, and orgeat syrup to create a sweet and tart flavor profile.

10. Best Seafood Market and Restaurant- LeeBe Fish

LeeBe Fish on Marco Island is a seafood lover’s dream, with both a market and a restaurant serving the freshest catches of the sea. 

They provide an extensive menu of fresh seafood, including a variety of fish, shrimp, crab, lobster, and more. Visitors can select from the day’s catch and bring the freshest items home to cook their own seafood feasts.

In addition to its market and restaurant, it also provides catering services for special parties and occasions and shipping options for individuals who wish to experience fresh seafood at home, even if they are not on Marco Island. 

The best time to visit Lee Be Fish Company is at lunch or dinner when the restaurant is bustling with both residents and tourists eager to sample the freshest fish in town.

What to Eat:

Get their big platter, which includes fried shrimp, scallops, clams, and fish, and is ideal for individuals who want to try a little bit of everything. Then, for a true seafood delicacy, a classic New England-style lobster roll with chunks of luscious lobster meat swirled in a creamy dressing and served on a buttery bun.

Finally, make sure to try their famous crab cake sandwich and crab cakes. These handmade crab cakes are cooked with fresh crab flesh, seasoned to perfection, and served with a tart remoulade sauce. 

11. Best Family-Owned Restaurant- STONEWALLS

Source / License: TripAdvisor

Stonewalls, located in the heart of Marco Island, has been delighting locals and visitors alike with its wonderful food and pleasant environment making it one of the best restaurants on Marco Island. Stonewalls take pride in providing a pleasant setting where customers may have a wonderful dining experience as a family-owned and operated institution.

The Deck at 560 has a traditional and timeless beauty about it, with every piece of the design meticulously curated to create a great dining experience. Warm colors, soft lighting, and comfy seating configurations combine to surround guests with a sense of calm and comfort.

The restaurant’s walls are also filled with fine artwork and souvenirs, which provide a sense of sophistication and character to the ambiance.

Stonewalls also have an exceptional wine list, with a large selection of fine wines that nicely match the food. It is best visited during evening hours because the restaurant has a dynamic and exciting ambiance that is ideal for a night out or a special event.

What to Eat:

Don’t know what to eat? Get their Chicken Piccata, a flavorful and satisfying option, a classic Italian dish featuring tender chicken breast cooked in a tangy lemon caper sauce served with a side of pasta or vegetables.

Another healthy and delicious option for seafood lovers is their grilled salmon featuring fresh salmon fillet served with a choice of sauces and sides, perfect for a lighter meal. Cap it off with Homemade Cheesecake, made in-house with rich and creamy cheesecake, topped with fresh berries or caramel sauce, a sweet ending to a memorable meal.

12. Best Waterfront Dining-  Mango’s Dockside Bistro

Mango’s Dockside Bistro, located along Marco Island’s picturesque shoreline, is a hidden gem for culinary connoisseurs looking for a one-of-a-kind eating experience. It offers stunning views of the marina from its great location overlooking the lovely waters of the Gulf of Mexico.

The restaurant has a comfortable and casual atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating, allowing customers to dine while taking in the mild sea breeze and breathtaking waterfront views. 

Mango’s Dockside Bistro also has a full-service bar with a variety of cocktails, wines, and craft brews.  It is best visited around sunset when the panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico and the marina are just spectacular. On some evenings, Mango’s Dockside Bistro also features live music, which adds a dynamic and engaging touch to your eating experience.

What to Eat:

Begin with the Caribbean Jerk Chicken, a delectable dish of marinated and grilled chicken with Caribbean-inspired spices, served with tropical fruit salsa and coconut rice. 

Another one-of-a-kind dish is the Blackened Grouper Sandwich, a savory sandwich with a blackened grouper fillet served on toasted bread with lettuce, tomato, and a zesty remoulade sauce. Lastly, try their Key Lime Pie for dessert, a traditional Florida treat prepared with key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and a graham cracker crust. 

13. Best Island Food- The Deck at 560

The Deck at 560 is a Marco Island, Florida, seaside restaurant that is well-known for its breathtaking panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico and its laid-back atmosphere. The restaurant has both indoor and outdoor seating, so diners may enjoy the mild sea breeze and spectacular views while they eat.

The Deck at 560’s culinary focus is on fresh seafood and American cuisine. The restaurant takes pleasure in using locally sourced ingredients to create dishes that highlight the finest of the region’s flavors and culinary traditions.

It also features a full-service bar with a large range of handcrafted cocktails, expertly picked wines, locally brewed craft beers, and a great cuisine. The bar is an ideal accompaniment to the dining experience, allowing customers to indulge in delectable libations that complement their meals.

While dinner time is the best time to visit The Deck at 560, as it offers a prime opportunity to relish their remarkable cuisine, arriving just before sunset can also be a delightful experience.

What to Eat:

They have a daily special with the day’s fresh fish, prepared in a number of ways, such as grilled, blackened, or baked, and served with tasty accompaniments.  Another famous meal is their shrimp and grits, which has large shrimp cooked in a flavorful sauce and served over creamy, cheesy grits. 

Another popular appetizer is the Key West conch fritters, which are crispy fritters cooked with tender conch meat, bell peppers, and spices and served with a tangy dipping sauce.

14. Best Comfort Foods- The Boulevard (Formerly Known As Philly Grille)

The Boulevard, known initially as Philly Grille, is a prominent Marco Island, Florida restaurant. It is a casual eating restaurant that serves American cuisine, concentrating on Philly-style cheesesteaks, sandwiches, and other comfort foods.

With indoor and outdoor seating, the restaurant boasts a casual and pleasant ambiance. The design is sleek and appealing, creating a comfortable atmosphere for customers.  It is also family-friendly, as it offers a relaxed atmosphere and a menu that includes sandwiches, burgers, salads, appetizers, and other American favorites. 

The Boulevard takes pride in its friendly service and seeks to offer its customers a pleasant eating experience.

Their happy hour deals and lively social atmosphere makes them more special. The best time to visit depends on personal preferences. However, it is normally open for lunch and dinner seven days a week.

What to Eat:

Try the Classic Philly cheesesteaks with various meat options such as steak or chicken, cooked with onions, peppers, and melted cheese, served on a hoagie roll. They also have salad options like mixed greens, vegetables, and dressing choices, such as Caesar salad, Cobb salad, or garden salad, with or without added protein options like grilled chicken or shrimp.

Other American comfort foods like macaroni and cheese, meatloaf, fried chicken, or mashed potatoes with gravy are also available. 

15. Best Bar and Grill- Stilts Bar & Grill

Stilts Bar & Grill is a well-known waterfront restaurant on Marco Island, Florida. Stilts Bar & Grill, known for its casual and laid-back ambiance, provides a comfortable eating experience with breathtaking views of the sea.

It is a well-known restaurant with varied and tempting cuisine that includes seafood and American fare. Stilts Bar & Grill’s culinary crew takes great delight in crafting their outstanding dishes using fresh, locally produced ingredients. Stilts Bar & Grill has something for every pallet, from exquisite seafood delights to classic American favorites.

One of Stilts Bar & Grill’s attractions is their daily happy hour when guests can enjoy attractive bargains on drinks and food. The restaurant’s lively and warm ambiance makes it a great place to unwind with friends.

What to Eat:

Try their Fresh Seafood Platters, which consists of shrimp, fish, and crab, which may be served in platters with various preparations, such as grilled, blackened, or fried. 

You can also sample their juicy burgers, including classic options like the Stilts Burger with all the fixings, as well as specialty burgers with unique toppings and flavor combinations. Their appetizers like coconut shrimp, calamari, and conch fritters are another crowd favorite. 

FAQs

Resources:

• (SuperTravel) SnapTravel Review: Is it Helpful for Travelers?
• Top Places to Travel Without a Passport from the US
• Travel Essentials for Women
• Is WayAway Legit? WayAway Review